It aint over till its over...
Goldman SIV deal shows banks urged to come cleanBy Elena Moya - Analysis
LONDON (Reuters) -
Goldman Sachs's (GS.N: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz) bail-out of a $7 billion Structured Investment Vehicle shows investors are pushing hard for banks to clean up troubled assets -- and could speed up billions worth of new writedowns.The proposed restructuring of Cheyne Finance, together with accountancy firm Deloitte DLTE.UL, could cut a Gordian knot and free up a backlog of unsold toxic assets in a sellers-only market that has neither buyers, nor prices.
But the deal, announced this week,
may also be the starting point of a new round of bank writedowns, bringing new losses and overshadowing any resulting transparency.
"Investors are definitely pushing banks to kitchen-sink their bad assets," Jim Irvine, head of Structured Products at Henderson Global Investors said.
"They want them to come out clean -- there's great concern that certain banks, including German banks, still haven't done that."
Markets are still grappling with a huge overhang of devalued assets after the crisis, and Europe alone has a backlog of about $116 billion of unsold leverage loans that banks are feeling under pressure to offload, according to estimates.
There are billions of dollars worth of assets in SIVs -- off-balance sheet vehicles banks have set up to boost their financial firing power -- that need revaluing.In subprime mortgage-related assets, global banks have already disclosed losses of $165 billion or 80 percent of the forecast total, leaving the remainder still to be announced, according to Fitch ratings agency research.
Investors are wary of sudden losses such as those from UBS (UBSN.VX: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz), the Swiss bank that wrote down assets in three consecutive rounds totaling $37 billion, making it Europe's biggest victim of the credit squeeze.
STEEP DISCOUNTSIn a sign just how much more money is still at risk, the Cheyne restructuring -- which aims to free assets in the SIV by pricing and selling some of the portfolio through an auction -- is expected to lead to steep discounts.
The fund's value -- $7 billion at receivership -- is expected to stand around $4 billion now.One restructuring banker, speaking under the condition of anonymity, said he expected a discount of five to 10 basis points in the auction, so that the portfolio could be sold for about 55 to 60 pence in the pound.
"The auction is likely to derive extremely low bids, given the volume of paper and the fact that few are expected to be sold," credit strategist Suki Mann at SocGen said in a note.
Under the much-awaited plan Deloitte will auction some 10 percent of the portfolio, to value the assets, a number that sources familiar with the situation said corresponds to the minority of creditors who want to cash out.
Goldman Sachs will then set an off-balance-sheet investment vehicle that will issue securities to former SIV senior creditors, who will hold the rest of the assets.
"
Considering almost half of the SIV portfolio's underlying assets were linked to U.S. residential mortgages (...), the senior noteholders may crystallize significant losses," a recent research note by Calyon said.
The Cheyne deal is innovative because it offers senior creditors different options -- either cashing in or holding on to the assets -- despite the fact that they all are equally entitled to remaining value in the fund.
MARK-TO-MYTHIn a sign the credit crisis is far from over, U.S. investment bank Lehman Brothers (LEH.N: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz) last week announced plans to raise $6 billion, following its first quarterly loss as a public company. Goldman Sachs earlier this week disclosed losses of $775 million in credit products.
Investment banks' losses are partially based on their mark-to-model practices, which confuses the market because the valuations are not based on actual trades, but on models, with each bank using its own specific methods."You price something but you don't know if anybody in the market is going to meet you at that price," a person familiar with the methods said, under the condition of anonymity. "You need real trades to be transparent."
Yet slowly, transparency and liquidity are returning to even the most arcane corners of the market, allowing banks to reduce those assets that are exclusively valued by models, said Tom Jenkins, a credit analyst at Royal Bank of Scotland.
And the Cheyne restructuring is a sign that regulators, auditors, rating agencies and powerful investors such as sovereign wealth funds are pushing banks to finally address the issue and price assets at a realistic level.
"It's not in banks' interest to try to camouflage their assets," Jenkins said.