Not vested. From DMG:-
Shipyard disappointment in Brazil?The news: According to an
Upstream article, an engineering director with Petrobras, Renato Duque, has stated that, in principle,
only one seven-rig package will be awarded. Other key takeaways are:
(1) Petrobras will be ruling on some final disqualification appeals and start negotiations with the lowest bidder for the drillship package. The rigs are expected to be delivered between 2014 and 2017. The article also highlighted that there is a chance Petrobras may negotiate with the participating shipyards to order fewer rigs per yard and that a
re-tender process may be considered.
(2) There are possible awards in the second category for two Petrobras owned rigs – one per yard and the bids are being analysed by Petrobras. EAS (Estaleiro Atlantico Sul), a unit backed by Samsung Heavy Industries and Keppel are the two lowest bidders for the second category.
(3) Petrobras is also keeping its options open for contracting chartered rigs and these rigs
must also be constructed in Brazil. Keppel is involved in six out of the 12 rigs proposed to Petrobras.
Our comments: Should this piece of news from Upstream comes true, share prices of
Keppel and Sembcorp Marine are likely to take the news negatively given that market expects Petrobras to
award the full four packages to four different bidders. Estaleiro Atlantico Sul (EAS), a unit backed by Samsung, is the lowest bidder with a bid of US$4.65b to build seven drillships, 10% lower than the prices submitted by Keppel and Sembcorp and within Petrobras working budget of US$700m/rig.
We have previously highlighted that there is potential downside risk to the Petrobras drillship tender given the
keen competition and aggressive pricing by domestic yards.
Between the two Singapore-based shipyards, Keppel is in a better position to win some orders from the second package in which they have the second lowest bid to build a semi-submersible rig, and the chartered units whereby Keppel is working together with rig owners.
We have a Buy rating on Keppel (TP: S$12.00) and a Neutral rating on Sembcorp Marine (TP: S$4.70) and downward adjustment to TPs may be on the cards if the yards fail to win the drillships orders.
http://www.remisiers.org/cms_images/15D ... marine.pdf
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"