20090114 Macquarie Sun Hung Kai Properties
Good sales; already priced-in
Event
We revisit the investment profile of SHKP following the positive price move of 7% (14% outperformance to HSI) over the last month. We retain our Underperform rating given the undemanding valuation against the historical track record over the past bear markets.
Impact
Good ramp up of property sales but already priced-in: SHKP has improved its secured profit for FY09 over the past two months as it initiated three project launches that have generated positive responses. It lifted its secured profit to 65% from 7% in October 2008. We consider the current share price has already factored in the improvement.
Limited China contribution: Given the current market conditions in China, we expect SHKP to generate limited contribution form China, no matter if it is development sales or rental income. In other words, its earnings base remains highly reliant on the Hong Kong contribution.
Risk to our call: In our view, the key risk lies on the better than expected positive response to its planned property launches in Hong Kong. The upcoming launch of the Cullinan, scheduled to be after Chinese New Year (early February 2009), is likely to be a key barometer of market response to HK luxury residential.
Earnings revision
We raised our FY09 forecast by 2% but made insignificant changes to our FY10 and FY11 forecasts. Our earnings revision for FY09 is mainly to reflect the higher than expected development sales from the recent project launches.
Price catalyst
12-month price target: HK$50.90 based on a 45% discount to NAV methodology.
Catalyst: Stronger than expected response to its project launches over the next few months.
Action and recommendation
We reiterate our Underperform rating on SHKP and marginally revised down our valuation by 1% to HK$92.6/share and our target by 2% to HK$50.9/share based on an unchanged 45% target NAV discount. We think the improvement of its FY09 secured profit and the overall recovery of primary and secondary volumes has triggered the uptrend of SHKP. At the current share price, it is now trading at an unattractive valuation of 28% NAV discount and 15.8x FY09 PER.
\We believe it is too early to position into SHKP for a substantial recovery of the HK residential sector given that the economic macro data is likely to disappoint and HK physical prices and volumes will likely remain volatile over the next few months. We see a potential 23% downside on SHKP from current level.