by winston » Thu Sep 04, 2014 4:27 pm
vested
Refuelling cash to shop for shops
SSG SP / SHEN.SI | ADD - Maintained | S$0.71 /TP S$0.73
Mkt.Cap:US$784.90m | Avg.Daily Vol:US$1.02m | Free Float:28.00%
Sheng Siong announced an S$80m share placement to fund site acquisitions for new store growth. The equity-raising will dilute FY15 EPS by 8.67%. The stock has taken a beating since the announcement and we revise down our target price to S$0.73, still based on 21.7x FY15 P/E (discount to Dairy Farm International), due to the dilution.
We maintain our Add rating only because the stock already tumbled.
We look forward to potential catalysts of
1) concrete store growth plans, and
2) more visibility on China expansion plans.
What Happened
Sheng Siong did a share placement yesterday (3 September 2014), issuing 120m shares at S$0.67/share, adding ~S$79m (net of fees) of capital and causing 8.7% dilution. Outstanding shares rise to 1,504m (previous: 1,384m. We trim our FY15 EPS by 8%.
What We Think
Our immediate reaction is a negative, since this creates immediate dilution without any foreseeable earnings upside. We see this as a replenishment of its cash pile.
1H14 ending net cash (S$95m) will dwindle down to ~$30m, after paying for Tampines (~S$65m). This placement takes the post-Tampines cash pile back to S$110m, giving them the means to bid for sites, if needed.
Sheng Siong still has to pay for J9 (~S$55m by 2017) in future. We expect the funds to be used for selective acquisition of new sites for growth, or sites on some of the existing outlets with expiring leases.
Sheng Siong will not be committing more funds into the China JV at this juncture. We view acquisition of existing sites as a defensive strategy to ensure that they can retain shop space in the face of competition. It will not boost earnings.
We see that strategy as a necessity but we are not too hot on it. We are more excited about new store growth, if it happens, since that will add to earnings. S$80m will probably buy it another 2 stores (~20k sq ft each), assuming capital values of ~S$2k/sq ft. Sheng Siong has 33 stores now.
Buying retail stores is an asset-heavy strategy that is equivalent to putting capital into hard assets that generate RoEs of 4-6%, vs. a business ROE of 25% ROE i.e. not good The question is whether it will be buy new or existing stores, management sounds like they do have new store targets.
What You Should Do
We maintain our Add rating only because share price has tumbled, reacting to the dilution. Our fully-diluted target price is revised to S$0.73 (from S$0.79), factoring in the effect of the placement.
Our grouse with Sheng Siong is that it did not have store growth to drive earnings. This placement is clearly in preparation of store growth and we will not be to negative, despite the dilution.
Previous "Sheng Siong Group" reports...
24/7/14 Co.Flash When the stars align (AD, S$0.66 /TP:0.79)
23/7/14 Co.Results Margin surprise from efficiency (AD, S$0.67 /TP:0.79)
25/4/14 Co.Results Squeezing blood from stone (AD, S$0.60 /TP:0.75)
Source: CIMB
It's all about "how much you made when you were right" & "how little you lost when you were wrong"